Questions asked by the community about Intelligence investigations into the Christchurch terrorist attacks.

17.3 Before 15 March 2019, how many national security investigations have been carried out on Muslim individuals, associations or institutions? The New Zealand Security Intelligence Service told us that their investigations focus on individuals, not associations or institutions (see Part 8, chapter 5). Approximately 30–40 individuals were on the investigative prioritization (watch) list being investigated by the New Zealand Security Intelligence Service at any given time in recent years. Most of these individuals were assessed by the New Zealand Security Intelligence Service as supporters of Dā’ish. New Zealand Police told us that, before 15 March 2019, most of their counter-terrorism investigations were focused on the threat of Islamist extremism (see Part 8, chapter 6). The limitations of New Zealand Police’s recording practices mean that exact numbers are not available. There was no centralized information system for recording national security leads, the actions taken, outcomes of investigation, and characteristics of complainants, victims or offenders (such as religion).

Before 15 March 2019, how many national security investigations have been carried out on white supremacist or right-wing extremist individuals, associations or institutions?

The New Zealand Security Intelligence Service’s baselining project on domestic right-wing extremism, which started in mid-2018, generated ten leads relevant to right-wing extremism (see Part 8, chapter 5). These leads were treated according to the New Zealand Security Intelligence Service’s leads management process. Some of these leads remained open as at 15 March 2019.

While we have seen evidence that New Zealand Police had conducted national security investigations into activities of suspected white supremacists or right-wing extremists before 15 March 2019 (see Part 8, chapter 6), the limitations of New Zealand Police’s recording practices mean that exact numbers are not available.  After 15 March 2019, New Zealand Police compiled a list of 1,700 individuals who had potential right-wing extremist characteristics from a review of their intelligence holdings. They told us that they had never attempted to do this before 15 March 2019. New Zealand Police told us that the accuracy and reliability of the information used to compile the list was variable and required further risk assessment. New Zealand Police collaborated with the New Zealand Security Intelligence Service and New Zealand Customs Service after 15 March 2019 to refine and prioritize the agencies’ leads on right-wing extremist individuals and groups in New Zealand

The public awareness of ‘Far Right Extremism’ and ‘White Supremacy’ reporting was expanded by the propaganda machine (Mainstream Media) in the later part of 2018. At the time I petitioned 6521 signatures objecting the UN Global Compact of Migration.  Speeches were held mostly in Aotea Square Auckland. Freedom of speech was also on the menu as police camera’s were in our faces, and I was ordered to not attend protests by the police. At time I was producing You Tube video’s as to why I objected to NZ signing the UN Global Compact of Migration.  Byron Clark Workers Socialist Party cherry picked edited my video’s. After the CH CH Mosque Attacks 15/3/2019 he met up with a group of Muslims telling them I inspired the Mosque attacks. He then went on to author a book titled FEAR ‘The underground of the Far – Right in NZ where he stated I inspired the Mosque Attacks. His book is in the Government National Archives and is still being sold in NZ in Whitcouls book shops etc., I laid complaints to Human Rights Commission, Broadcasting Commission to no avail. Concern was that he endangered my family by sating I inspired the Mosque attacks.  This is surely the Tyranny of Human Rights in New Zealand.

It was in 2018 that NZ Police and Security Services were being trained to be aware of right wing extremism and  white supremacy.  After March 15^th 2019 1700 NZrs were listed by Police in reference to be potentially far right extremist and white supremacist. Christchurch inquiry reported NZ Police inaccuracy of this list

The Royal Inquiry to the Christchurch Attacks brings out some very interesting information that the propaganda machine (mainstream media) and the political cronies behind the closed doors of Parliament will not openly share with the public of New Zealand. At press conferences the mainstream media reporters will not ask many questions that New Zealanders should have answers too.

This video will  give further information as to what you may or may not have known about the history of these events globally, nationally, of course there is much more to tell

RESEARCHER Carol Sakey

Click within image for Video

Nicola Willis was asked for a response to Barry Youngs Court Case and she responses ” she would not comment on a case before the court”. . But she said that, in general, the unauthorized access, use or leaking of government information was disappointing. She said “such actions had the potential to damage public trust and confidence in the neutrality of the public service “Well Nicola Willis how about the already thousands of data files leaked from govt agencies.. Health records, Bereavement records, Clinical Records, Post Mortem records, Cancer Patient Records. Inadequate Govt agencies data system security putting all NZrs at risk of having their private information put in the hands of criminals, during the COVID Pandemic and before. This is evidential through public information via Minister Of Health, DHB reports and Beehive Speeches. Data Systems inadequate, outdated posing serious cyber attacks. Thousands upon thousands of files. All exposed to criminals, the dark web. The evidence is truly evidential. The Government Agencies especially Ministry Of Justice, Ministry Of Health- Te Whatu Ora- Health NZ. Brooke Van Velden gave a very interesting speech in Parliament about Cancer patients having to travel outside their areas to be able to access radiation, cancer treatment because of cyber attacks. Doctors had to revert to writing on white boards.The government knew there was a problem. The Privacy Commission reported :-THE PRIVACY COMMISSION ANNOUNCED “ Organizations, Government Agencies “Personal data pertaining to New Zealanders, those agencies, orgs, are responsible in protecting information, keep it safe from cyber attacks, cyber threats under the Privacy Act. A failure to do so is a breach of the Privacy Act. They must put things right to protect New Zealanders personal information, keep it safe from cyber attacks. There is no room for any organizations, govt agencies to be complacent in protecting New Zealand private information held in their data systems.

TRUST IS HARD WON… EASILY LOST’….Many New Zealanders have lost all trust with the government. I do not see Apa of Te Whatu Ora admitting the 1,000’s of Health Files etc., that have already been leaked by way of Mercury IT. That was not something she chose not to speak about, its damming evidence on Government Agencies part. Ministers, including Andrew Little admitted to all olf this. Mercury IT admitted to this cyber attacking .I understand you cannot be involved in an ongoing court case, and that the government is currently seeking expert advice to put this serious Cyber Security risks of New Zealander to right, however admittance of the governments own guilt should be publicly exposed as it is Barry Young being criminalized and it appears the government is beyond being criminalized or held accountable to the Privacy Commission. Parliamentary Immunity is unjustifiable and is criminal in itself putting so many NZrs lives at risk by not updating cyber security systems. In my Research I have been following speeches within the Beehive for years, therefore I am well aware of these Cyber attacks and the inadequate cyber security system that exists and the concerns as to updating that system, the failing of the follow-up to this by ministers.

My past working history is several decades working in paid employment in Crisis Intervention. Restorative Justice, Have written papers for Judge Brown. Have been a member of the NZ Youth Court Committee. A Family Therapist. Studied Social Policy. Played a key part in setting up a first ever pilot in NZ as to supporting victims of Youth Crime. Undertook some training at the Police College as to Victims affected by Homicides and Suicides. Working on call to Police 24 x 7. Having access to incident files. Attending many workshops, voluntary End of Story time writing assisting those in Hospice write their end of life story’s for their loved ones. Worked voluntarily for Age Care. I have attended 6 Treaty workshops.

Personally, I am a mother of four, grandmother of 25, great grandmother of 7, they are a mixture of cultures, ethnic groups and love them all.

Honesty is my Policy. I would appreciate your honesty in anticipation of a response to my email that holds great concern that New Zealanders are highly at risk of cyber attacks and Barry Young is being unjustly, unfairly targeted. The government (Te Whatu Ora-Health NZ) needs to take a look at itself in the mirror before pointing the finger at an innocent man.

RESEARCHER: Carol Sakey

TOO LATE TE WHATU ORA IT’S GONE GLOBAL….

Barry Young once again before the court yesterday 23^rd February  2024. Pleading Not Guilty as he is accused by Apa of Te Whatu Ora of a data leak of personal info referencing that of 12,000 or more online. Barry is charged with dishonestly speaking out about Te Whatu Ora  Health Agency  Data online. Judge Warburton remanded Barry Young on Bail. As Barry Young said as he was leaving court “Truth Is Not A Crime’. The article in mainstream propaganda again call Barry and Liz conspiracy theorist as the Weaponizing of Health unfolds worldwide, more information is being exposed by expert professional and medical professionals worldwide.  But Barry’s case is very significant as we have a smaller population, which is evidentiality of much use to those that are professionally medically exposing the truth worldwide. Therefore NZ is on the map in this instance. All eyes on NZ.

Te Whatu Ora reported this is a complex investigation, there is a collaboration between national and international experts. They are starting to contact every person effected by Barry’s Leak of information. They are working with online security experts nationally, internationally to monitor for signs of the exposure of data online HOW CONVENIENT

HOW CONVENIENT- COVER YOUR OWN ARSES.. RNZ Report 6/12/2022 cyber attack hits 1,000’s of coronial files and health records, investigation into digital security. Ministry of Justice and Whatu Ora hold IT Provider Mercury IT responsible. 14,500 Coroners files, 4,000 Post Mortem Files of who died between November 2018 and November 2022  HOW CONVENIENT  NZrs personal information right across NZ breached.   20^th November 2011 8,500 bereavements, care services file and 5,000 Cardias and Inherited Disease records cycler attacked. Privacy Commissioner notified 20/11/2022  HOW CONVENIENT

Ministry of Justice and Te Whatu Ora said “no evidence of any unauthorized access or downloading of files however Ministry Chief Operating Officer Carl Crafter said “this could not be ruled out, this is a possibility” He said We need to acknowledge this information is sensitive, six Regulatory Health Authorities have been hit. Te Whatu Ora responding “ We realize this is distressing”, and “we are working with cyber security experts to determine the full nature and extent of the impact of this incident”

Reference was made to a 2021 Waikato DHB report on Cyber attacks which said “ Te Whatu Ora needs to think like a hacker when building its security software”. In May 2021 ransomware cyber attacks brought DHBs, hospitals, services to a complete halt, as systems were worked on to be restored. Doctors had to work on whiteboards, and use hard copies for gathering information. 6^th December 2022 1,000’s of coroners files, post mortem reports caught up in Ministry of Justice hack. Referencing 14,500 coroners files, 4000 post mortum reports nationwide of a sensitive personal information. Action was to be taken by National Cyber Security Centre, Privacy Commission, Police & CERT-NZ to investigate the extent of the incident which exposing that of Mercury IT that is commissioned to these DHBs etc., being at the heart of the cyber attack.

NZ Public were told to watch out for suspicious texts, emails unusual things happens, accounts, bank accounts etc.,

Stuff NZ reported 6/12/ 2022 Cyber Attack on external company Mercury IT. Bereavement files Cardio Arrest reports Middlemore Hospital access to  8500  bereavement files dating back to 2015. 5,500 records  data dating back to 2011, disease data dating back to 2011 Auckland Wellington Tauranga and Nelson clinicians files. Mercury IT confirmed the cyber attacks in a statement dated 30/11/2022 that files had been effected nationwide. Mercury IT providing a wide range of IT Services to customers across NZ, governments, orgs, etc.,

16/12/2022 Te Whatu Ora hacked files before High Court. Te Whatu Ora and Health NZ cyber attacked files 14,500 coroners files, 4,000 other reports. Ransome ware cyber attack. References have been made a number of times that urgent work was required as to cyber security that cyber attacks were happening daily, saying this is an evolving situation. RNZ reported that DHBs were cyber attacked this is catastrophic for patient safety. Cyber attacks on high alert. Spokes person from Telehealth Leadership Group advising the Ministry that ‘phishing scams are efficient and ruthless. DHB Southern Region noticing cyber attacks over a period of 7 days.

NZ Herald May 18^th 2021 NZ Hospitals battle daily cyber attacks. All DHBs across NZ face Cyber attacks in various forms (source Ministry Of Health) Cyber Attacks target COVID19 Pandemic HOW CONVENIENT WHEN INVESTIGATIONS, INQUIRIES, MASKING INFORMATION, MASKING THE TRUTH.   NZ Parliament 29/6/2021 Speakers in the House discuss DHB  Cyber Attacks referring to Ransome ware, the debate was declined because they wanted to discuss budget. Brooke Van Veldon speaker said “there is significant evidence that NZrs personal infor – data is on the dark web, this is a huge concern, ongoing incidences. People who are undergoing radiation therapy for cancer have had to travel beyonf their residential area to other areas in NZ to receive cancer treatment. Referenced also 400,000 NZrs could be affected, these are vulnerable people whom are already suffering  from ongoing serious harm.

Investigations have shown that DHBs lack vital IT Infrastructure, network security is outdated inadequate and this has increased cyber security attacks, there are serious security issues, therefore patient private data is never safe, and has not been without risk. HOW CONVENIENT. 30^th May 2023 Ministry of Health referenced a report that DHB Computer systems seriously need an upgrade, government failed to follow through.   Andrew Little confirmed what Brooke Van Veldon had said as to her serious concerns as to cyber attacks, saying “patients information is accessible to others worldwide We have known that for some time”. Melissa Lee saying that Cyber Attackers go for weaknesses.

Parliament 2019 discussed cyber attacks in NZ the need for upgrading inadequate data IT Security Systems. Stuff NZ reported 27/5/2021 Privacy Commission warned DHBs to address security failings. December 18^th 2023 Lisa Fong speech as 2023 NZITF Conference spoke about the NZ Internet Task Force referencing the November 2023 Cyber Threat  Report- Domestic and International. Linking more domestic incidents to financially motivated crims and the growing effective malicious cyber tools, vulnerabilities the public are facing, infrastructure is made easier for cyber attackers to work at scale, sophistication causing national harm. And the need to improve NZ Cyber Security System Framework, saying she was getting expert advice from across NZ. IN OTHER WORDS THE GOVERNMENT HAD NOT GOT THEIR SHITE TOGETHER LEFT THOUSANDS UPON THOUSANDS OF NZRS EXPOSED TO THE DARK WEB , CRIMS THAT UTILIZE CYBER ATTACKS USING THEIR PRIVATE INFORMATION.

Stuff NZ 23/2/2024 Accused former Public Servant calls on other would-be whistleblowers. Barry accused of stealing large amounts of health data. Wellington District Court Barry was charged with ‘dishonestly accessing databases belonging to his former employer Health NZ-Te Whatu Ora. Barry said “I urge anyone in the Police, anyone in the services who have access to information that needs to come out, please, please do the right thing and end this”. Te Whatu Ora is accusing Barry of leaking 12,000 of peoples personal information as a result of a data breach. HOW COVENIENT. HOW MANY DATA BREACHES IS TO WHATU ORA, GOVERNMENT AND OTHER ORGANIZATIONS ARE RESPONSIBLE FOR.  AND YOU SEVERELY ATTACK THIS COURAGEOUS MAN.  HOW CONVENIENT.

THE PRIVACY COMMISSION ANNOUNCED “ Organizations, Government Agencies “Personal data pertaining to New Zealanders, those agencies, orgs, are responsible  in protecting information, keep it safe from cyber attacks, cyber threats under the Privacy Act.  A failure to do so is a breach of the Privacy Act. They must put things right to protect NZrs personal information, keep it safe from cyber attacks. There is no room for any organizations, govt agencies to be complacent in protecting New Zealand private information held in their data systems. TRUST IS HARD WON… EASILY LOST’

HOW CONVENIENT, PROTECTING THE BACKS OF THOSE THAT DID LEAK THOUSANDS OF DATA FILES, NZRS PRIVATE INFO, HEALTH RECORDS, BEREAVEMENT RECORDS, POST MORTUM, CLINICAL CARDIO… JUST TARGET BARRY YOUNG FOR ALL THOSE INJUSTICES, SERIOUS HARMS THE GOVERNMENT HAS DONE TO VUNERABLE NEW ZEALANDERS.

https://www.ncsc.govt.nz/news/looking-to-the-future/